Santorini Is a Beautiful Place to Stand in a Line

Santorini is gorgeous. I want to be clear about that before I say everything else. The caldera is one of the most dramatic landscapes in Europe — a volcanic crater filled with sea, ringed by cliffs, topped with white villages that cling to the edge like they’re deciding whether to jump. The light is extraordinary. The blue domes are real. The sunsets are, objectively, among the best on the planet.

Now let me tell you about the experience of actually being there.

The Lines

You will wait for the sunset. In Oia, the northwestern tip of the island where the sunset is most famous, the castle walls begin filling at 5 PM for an 8 PM sunset. Three hours. People bring blankets, wine, camping chairs. They stake out positions with the territorial intensity of concert-goers at general admission. By 7 PM, the crowd is four rows deep and someone’s elbow is in your photograph and you can hear eight different languages being spoken simultaneously and a man behind you is narrating the entire experience into his phone for an audience that isn’t there.

The sunset happens. It’s beautiful. The crowd applauds. I don’t know who they’re applauding — the sun, presumably, which has been doing this for four and a half billion years and does not need the encouragement.

You will wait for the restaurant. Santorini’s famous caldera-view restaurants require reservations days in advance for dinner, and when you arrive, you’ll discover that the tables are packed so tightly that your romantic evening includes the conversation of the couple next to you, who are arguing about whether to visit the volcano tomorrow. The food is secondary to the view, and the prices reflect the view, not the food. A grilled sea bass that would cost €18 in Athens costs €45 with a caldera backdrop.

You will wait for the photo. Every iconic spot on the island — the blue dome churches in Oia, the red beach, the lighthouse — has a queue. Not a formal queue, just a cluster of people politely cycling through the same frame. Step in, smile, step out. The person behind you is already positioning their phone. The experience of Santorini’s most beautiful spots is the experience of waiting to photograph them and then moving on.

What Nobody Tells You

The beaches are not good. I know the brochures show them. The red beach is dramatic — red volcanic cliffs over dark sand — but it’s small, crowded, and the access path is technically closed due to rockfall danger, which doesn’t stop anyone. Kamari and Perissa have black volcanic sand that absorbs heat like a frying pan. By noon, walking barefoot is an act of commitment.

The cruise ships. On any given day in high season, three to five cruise ships anchor in the caldera and disgorge thousands of passengers into Fira and Oia. The streets, which were designed for donkeys, absorb this volume the way a straw absorbs a firehose. The shops become impassable. The paths become one-way by necessity. Between 10 AM and 4 PM, the towns belong to the ships.

The donkeys. They still use donkeys to carry tourists up the steps from the old port in Fira. The donkeys look exactly how you’d expect animals to look who spend their lives carrying tourists up six hundred steps in the heat. I took the cable car. I suggest you do the same.

The Case for Santorini

All of this is true and none of it means you shouldn’t go. Santorini earned its reputation. The caldera is genuinely awe-inspiring. The villages are genuinely beautiful. The light does something at golden hour that I’ve never seen replicated anywhere — it turns the white buildings pink, then gold, then amber, and the whole island looks like it’s being remembered rather than seen.

The wine is underrated. The Assyrtiko grape, grown in volcanic soil, produces a white wine that’s mineral and sharp and tastes like the sea. Visit Santo Wines for the tasting and the view, or better, visit one of the smaller producers — Gavalas, Hatzidakis — where the wine is better and the crowd is nonexistent.

The villages beyond Oia and Fira are worth finding. Pyrgos, in the center of the island, has a medieval castle, a handful of restaurants, and approximately zero tourists. Emporio is a fortified village where the streets were designed to confuse pirates. They still confuse visitors, which is charming rather than frustrating when you’re not competing with a cruise ship crowd.

The Alternative

If what you want is the Santorini experience — volcanic beauty, Cycladic architecture, sunsets, wine — without the lines, the ships, and the €45 sea bass, go to Milos. Or go to Folegandros. Or go to Sifnos. The Cyclades have dozens of islands that offer everything Santorini offers except the fame, and the absence of fame is the thing that makes the experience what Santorini’s experience used to be.

Santorini is a beautiful place. The experience of visiting it is an exercise in navigating the distance between beauty and the industry built around it. The beauty wins — it always wins on Santorini, because the caldera is that good and the light is that special. But it wins by a narrower margin than you’d expect.

Go if you want to. Just know what you’re signing up for. The sunset is free. Everything else will cost you — in money, in patience, in the particular exhaustion of being somewhere beautiful that everyone else in the world wants to be at the same time.

]]>